One Great Family - Two Great Restaurants
Quality Ingredients | Comfortable Atmosphere | Lunch & Dinner
Quality Ingredients
Comfortable Atmosphere
Lunch & Dinner
The Home of Milwaukee's Finest Italian Cuisine
BALISTRERI'S BLUEMOUND IN N and our ITALIAN/AMERICAN RISTORANTE locations offer outstanding, authentic cuisine made from locally produced, high-quality ingredients. We've been voted Best Late-Night Food by Milwaukee Magazine, as well as one of the area's top five fish fries and Milwaukee's best thin crust pizza.
Visit either of our two locations for the finest Italian cuisine in the Milwaukee area.
PLEASE CALL FOR RESERVATIONS
Balistreri's Bluemound Inn (Lunch or Dinner)
Balistreri's Italian/American Ristorante (Lunch Only)
Both dine-in and carryout are available.
Please call ahead for reservation availability as there is limited seating on evenings and weekends.
Bluemound Inn
Lunch Menu
Craving something fresh and flavorful for lunch? Check out Balistreri’s Bluemound Inn’s lunch menu—crafted with premium ingredients, local products, and over 50 years of family tradition.
Bluemound Inn
Dinner Menu
Treat yourself to a memorable dinner at Balistreri’s Bluemound Inn—where house-made cheese, locally sourced ingredients, and signature dishes await. Open late on weekends.
Bluemound Inn
Pizza Menu
Craving pizza done right? Balistreri’s Bluemound Inn serves up handcrafted pies topped with our signature house-made cheese and the freshest local ingredients—perfect for sharing or savoring solo.
Italian/American Ristorante Lunch Menu
Whether you're craving pasta, pizza, or something in between, Balistreri’s has your lunch covered—served fresh daily with a side of family-friendly charm and our famous ice cream drinks. Dine-in or carryout is available!
Italian/American Ristorante
Dinner Menu
From classic pasta entrees to award-winning thin crust pizza, Balistreri’s Italian/American Ristorante serves up all your favorite Italian dishes—plus our famous ice cream drinks! Join us any day of the week for dine-in or carryout in a warm, family-friendly setting.
Italian/American Ristorante Pizza Menu
From our award-winning thin crust to fresh, flavorful toppings, Balistreri’s Italian/American Ristorante pizza is a local favorite for a reason. Bring the family and taste the tradition! Reservations are recommended.
Premier Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee, WI
For over five decades, Balistreri’s has been a cornerstone of Milwaukee’s culinary scene, serving authentic Italian-American cuisine that captures the heart and soul of Italy while embracing the vibrant flavors of Wisconsin. With two cherished locations — Balistreri’s Italian-American Ristorante in Wauwatosa and Balistreri’s Bluemound Inn in Milwaukee — we’ve built a legacy of exceptional food, warm hospitality, and unforgettable dining experiences. Family-owned and operated since 1968, our restaurants are more than just places to eat; they’re gathering spots where locals and visitors alike come to share stories, savor meals, and create memories.
At Balistreri’s, we take pride in our commitment to quality. Our kitchens use locally sourced, high-quality ingredients to craft dishes that honor traditional Italian recipes while incorporating innovative touches that keep our menu fresh and exciting. From our legendary thin-crust pizzas to our hearty pastas, succulent steaks, and fresh seafood, every dish is prepared with care and passion. Whether you’re joining us for a casual lunch, a romantic dinner, or a late-night bite, our Italian restaurants in Milwaukee, WI create a welcoming atmosphere and attentive service where you’ll feel right at home.
A Tradition of Excellence
Since opening our doors, Balistreri’s has earned a reputation for excellence, consistently recognized as one of the top Italian restaurants in Milwaukee, WI. Our thin-crust pizzas, crafted by artisans who’ve honed their skills over decades, have been voted Milwaukee’s best by local publications. We’ve also been celebrated for our late-night dining, making us a go-to spot for those craving a delicious meal after hours. With an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau, our commitment to quality and customer satisfaction shines through in every aspect of our restaurants.
Our two locations offer distinct yet complementary experiences. Balistreri’s Italian-American Ristorante in Wauwatosa, located at 812 N 68th St, exudes a cozy, nostalgic charm with a nod to classic Italian-American dining. Its intimate setting and lively atmosphere make it perfect for family gatherings or a night out with friends. Balistreri’s Bluemound Inn, situated at 6501 W Bluemound Rd, offers a refined yet relaxed vibe, with an emphasis on fresh fish, steaks, and an extensive menu that caters to a variety of tastes. Both locations provide dine-in, carryout, and reservation options, ensuring convenience for every occasion.
Why Choose One of the Top Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee, WI?
Here’s what sets Balistreri’s apart as Milwaukee’s premier Italian dining destination:
- Legendary Thin-Crust Pizza: Our pizzas are crafted with a crispy, golden crust and topped with the freshest ingredients, from classic pepperoni to gourmet combinations like basil pesto with rock shrimp or our Milwaukee-inspired pizza with aged white cheddar and caramelized sauerkraut.
- Diverse Menu: Beyond pizza, our menu features a range of Italian classics like lasagna, linguine carbonara, and penne arrabbiata, alongside steaks, seafood, and gourmet sandwiches, ensuring something for every palate.
- Family-Friendly Atmosphere: Our warm, inviting spaces are perfect for families, date nights, or group celebrations, with holiday decorations that create a festive ambiance during special seasons.
- Late-Night Dining: Voted Milwaukee’s best late-night food by Milwaukee Magazine, we’re open late to satisfy your cravings, whether it’s a post-game pizza or a midnight pasta fix.
- Event-Friendly Services: From shuttle services to Milwaukee sporting and theater events to hosting special occasions like Mother’s Day or Thanksgiving, we make every visit memorable.
A Culinary Journey
At Balistreri’s, every dish tells a story. Our pizzas, with their light, airy crusts and bold flavors, reflect the artistry of our pizza makers, who undergo years of training to perfect their craft. Our pasta dishes are made with house-made sauces and fresh ingredients that transport you to the heart of Italy. For seafood lovers, our Bluemound Inn location offers dishes showcasing the freshest catches. Meat enthusiasts can indulge in our New York strip or blackened tenderloin tips, cooked to perfection and paired with locally sourced sides.
As one of the premier Italian restaurants in Milwaukee, WI, our commitment to quality extends to our bar, where you’ll find an extensive wine list, craft beers, martinis, and indulgent ice cream drinks. Whether you’re sipping a glass of wine with your meal or enjoying a post-dinner dessert cocktail, our bar enhances the Balistreri’s experience. During warmer months, our outdoor patio seating at Bluemound Inn offers a delightful al fresco dining option, perfect for soaking in Milwaukee’s vibrant energy.
Community and Connection
As a family-owned business, Balistreri’s is deeply rooted in the Milwaukee community. We’re proud to support local events and organizations, from food festivals to charity initiatives. Our restaurants are more than just dining spaces — they’re places where neighbors become friends, and every visit feels like coming home. We’re honored to have served generations of Milwaukee residents and look forward to welcoming new faces to our table.
Contact One of the Most Delicious Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee, WI
We’d love to hear from you or welcome you to one of our locations! Whether you’re planning a visit, placing a carryout order, or inquiring about event reservations, our team is here to assist. Join us at Balistreri’s, where every meal is a celebration of flavor, tradition, and community. We can’t wait to serve you.
Here's what our satisfied customers are saying...
At Balistreri's Bluemound Inn, we take pride in providing exceptional Italian cuisine to our customers. We would be grateful if you could share your thoughts about our restaurant with others. Your feedback helps us improve, and helps others make informed decisions. Please take a moment to leave a review of Balistreri's Bluemound Inn and let others know what you think.